The tip of the iceberg: The 50 minute conversation in context
Psychological Professions Week is approaching, and I’ve found myself reflecting on what the process of doing therapy actually involves. So I thought I’d let you into my world for a little while and show you how I experience it.
Therapy is often described as a conversation with a purpose, and it often looks remarkably like that over the 50 minutes you spend with your psychologist. But that conversation is only the tip of the iceberg. There is a lot going on beneath the surface – some of it during those 50 minutes and some of it before and after you ever enter the room.
What follows is my experience of that iceberg. Most psychologists I know would describe something broadly similar, but none of us works in exactly the same way. We bring our training and experience to the work, but also our own ways of thinking, noticing, understanding and making sense of the person sitting opposite us.
What do you mean the conversation is only part of what's going on?
While I'm listening to what you're telling me, I'm also watching and thinking. I'm noticing what you say, what you don't say and what seems important to you. I'm noticing what happens while you tell me – a change in your posture, looking away, becoming more animated or suddenly very still, laughing while you tell me something that doesn't sound very funny. None of those things is something I'm judging as good or bad, right or wrong. I'm curious about what they might mean for you.
And that is quite different from the listening we often do in ordinary conversation. Sometimes, even when we're paying close attention to someone, part of our attention is already being used to plan our response. What will I say when they've finished? Do I agree? Have I had a similar experience? What advice could I give? In therapy, I'm trying to use that attention differently. I'm not listening in order to work out what I think about what you're telling me, or to decide what I want to say next. I'm listening to understand you.
That means I'm remembering things you've told me before and wondering whether they connect with what I'm seeing and hearing now. I'm noticing patterns, changes and contradictions, not because I'm trying to catch you out, but because they may help me understand something that isn't yet obvious to either of us. I'm thinking about what I understand about you so far – and remaining willing to change that understanding as I learn more.
Of course I'm also making choices. Do I ask about that? Do I challenge it? Do I point out the connection I've just noticed, or is it more useful to let you get there yourself? Is that silence uncomfortable because you need me to fill it, or useful because you need some space to think? Sometimes the most important thing I do in a session is say something. Sometimes it's deciding not to.
So our conversation with a purpose isn't the sharing of experiences, ideas and advice that you might expect when talking to a friend. Some people find it a luxury to have a conversation in which they really are the focus. How nice to have time to think about me! Others find that surprisingly intimidating: What will she think of me? Am I being stupid? Am I doing this right?
My job is to create an environment, and a process, that best supports you. That's why I listen, observe and reflect. It's why I'm interested in understanding your experience rather than comparing it with my own, and why it's relatively rare for me to share my own experiences. If I do, there should be a reason for it that is about you, not me. This is your conversation.
Are you ready for me?
I work with many clients. The tip of the iceberg I’m describing here is the conversation we’ve just explored, with quite a lot of work going on below the waterline at the same time. But how do I set myself up to be present with you in that very particular way?
It starts before you arrive.
If this is our first session, I may already have had a conversation with you. I may have read a referral, or reviewed medical records, reports or other information you’ve been brave enough to share with me. Before we have even met, I’m aiming to understand something about what has brought you to me – while being careful not to decide that I understand you from what somebody else has written about you.
If we’ve met before, I need to move from the person I was just talking to, or whatever else I was doing, back to you. I’ll remind myself where we were when we last met. What were we talking about? What was important to you? Was there something you were going to try, think about or notice between sessions? Was there something I wondered about afterwards that I want to hold in mind today?
That 50-minute hour? There are many stories but little factual evidence about how it came to be. Some say it originated with the need for the founders of modern psychology to reflect with their students. We don’t really know. For me, those ten minutes around sessions matter. Personally, I generally try to schedule more if I can. They give me time to step out of one person's world before I step into another. I use some of that time to remind myself about you and your world and to become present in it again.
I’m not preparing a script or deciding in advance where our conversation should go. In fact, doing that would make it harder for me to listen properly when you arrive. I’m bringing myself back into your world so that when we start, I’m ready to meet you where you are today – which may, of course, be somewhere completely different from where either of us expected.
After we say goodbye…
When our 50 minutes are over, my work with you doesn't immediately stop.
Often, I'll sit for a moment and think about what has just happened. What felt important today? Did something change? Was there a moment when you became quieter, or more animated, or when something suddenly seemed to make more sense? Was there something I chose not to ask about that I might want to come back to?
I'm also thinking about whether what I've learned today changes my understanding of you. Psychologists sometimes call this formulation – essentially, the story we're developing about how you came to be where you are, what might be keeping you stuck there and, importantly, what might help you move forward. That story is never finished. Every conversation gives me another piece of the picture, and sometimes a piece that makes me rearrange quite a lot of the others.
I'll write my notes. They're not a transcript of our conversation, but a professional record of the things I need to remember and the work we're doing together. There may be something I want to read about, something I want to think about further, or an idea I want to explore when we next meet.
And sometimes I need another brain. Psychologists have supervision throughout our careers. That gives me somewhere to examine my thinking, to wonder whether I've missed something, to have my assumptions challenged and, sometimes, to think about my own reaction to what happened in the room. If I felt unusually protective of you, frustrated, worried or simply puzzled, I need to be curious about that too. Is that about me, or might my reaction be telling me something useful about what is happening between us?
And then, at some point, I need to put you down.
Not because I've stopped caring or thinking about our work, but because I can't remain in your world all day. I need to be able to leave it, just as I need to be able to enter it again when you come back.
Shared experience....
Psychological Professions Week is an opportunity to share something of what we do, and I hope I've given you a glimpse into my world. The conversation is the part of therapy you see, but there is much more happening below the waterline – before we meet, while we're talking and after we say goodbye. The privilege of sharing your world is never something I take for granted. It motivates me to be with you – above and below the waterline.
